Branding Beliefs from Around the Blogosphere

One of the things I love about marketing terms is how their elusive nature allows for open interpretation and individual definitions.

In my brain, branding is the art and science of forming an impression. The success of your brand is determined by how closely your customer’s experience meets (or exceeds!) their expectations.

Here’s what some of the blogosphere’s top bloggers have to say about branding:

Toby Bloomberg of Diva Marketing Blog: “The reason people belong to brands is similar to why people join a cult.”

Paul McEnany from Hee-Haw Marketing: “branding still has a job of not just pushing things to push them, but when they need to be pushed, and then pushing them in the right direction”

Russell Davies: “Branding is no longer the future of business…Not everything is a brand…Branding is being replaced by design/technology as the future of business.”

Seth Godin: “The key word, I think, is spiritual. Mythological brands make a spiritual connection with the user, delivering something that we can’t find on our own… or, at the very least, giving us a slate we can use to write our own spirituality on.”

Shel Holtz: “I wish I had a dollar for every session on brands and branding offered at every conference I ever attended; I could probably buy a new car. Brands are big, especially in the marketing and PR worlds. Maybe it’s time to focus elsewhere.”

Guy Kawasaki and How To Change the World: “at the end of the day, customers ultimately determine what your brand means. To a great degree, you take your best shot, and then you see what sticks. Or, more accurately, you see what customers make stick for you.”

John Jantsch of Duct Tape Marketing: “What if you interviewed a handful of clients and asked them this question: ‘What’s the ONE word you would use that best describes what we do well?‘…Now, how does everyone in your firm define and own that word…That’s how a small business brand is built, that’s how you differentiate your business.”

Rohit Bhargava with Influential Marketing Blog: “Everyone has brands that they are passionate about…and the rise of consumer generated media are just a few of the symptoms that would point anyone towards this conclusion.”

Chris Houchens and Shotgun Marketing Blog: “Press Releases don’t change public perception of your brand. Positive customer experiences do.”

Brad VanAuken of Branding Strategy Insider: “For profitable market share gains, one must focus on all of the drivers of customer brand insistence: awareness, accessibility, value, relevant differentiation and emotional connection.”

Martin Jelsema – The Branding Blog: “Before the more traditional tasks such as naming a company or creating a logo, branding is a strategic activity that defines the very business to be created. It involves assessing the market, paying attention to trends and positioning the company in relation to competitors. It is the junction where customer desire and company strengths cross. I call it the brand platform.”

Steve Miller – Two Hat Marketing Blog: “Your brand is what your customers think it is and what you think dosen’t matter.”

Mike Wagner – Own Your Brand: “Wise brand owners know they might own the original ideas, vision and meaning of their brand, but the significance is something customers own.”

Johnnie Moore – “Branding used to be about polishing and smoothing, to make shiny images of products and services that we’d all admire…Now branding needs to celebrate the rough… the inconsistent… different people saying different things about different bits of you.”

David Report: “A brand is a perception in the minds of the consumers.”

Laura Ries – The Origin of Brands: “Brands are simply an efficient means to an end. And powerful brands are those that stand for and represents a distinct category or concept in consumers’ minds.”

What about you? Leave your branding quote in our comments section and the best ones will get posted in a follow-up post.

 

FCW Insider Chris Dorobek Discusses Federal Blogs & Social Media

dorobek.jpgIn the past few days, we’ve been on the radio talking up federal social media, we’ve had B2G guru Mark Amtower discuss federal blogging trends, and we’ve even written a 1,000-mile view of the federal blogging market. We decided to give Chris Dorobek, editor-in-chief of Federal Computer Week and author of the FCW Insider, the last word on social media, and in particular, blogs in the federal market. For those of you who don’t know Federal Computer Week, it is by far the leading industry publication serving the pubic sector. Read this fascinating interview for Chris’s rich point of view as leader of FCW and as a blogger.

BB: How do you like blogging versus managing a publication?

CD: I’ll try to keep the other questions shorter, but I think it is important to lay out the framework here. The short answer is that, fortunately or unfortunately, this isn’t an either-or kind of question. I get to do both.

The long answer is that, to be honest, this can be challenging sometimes. But I think that this is the way of the world these days. The world of journalism is facing some real challenges in an age where all you need to be a publisher is an Internet connection. (I might note that I don’t think journalism is alone — these are challenging times for most organizations. What industry isn’t facing steep competition?)

For publishers, increasingly, we don’t get to define how we reach people. There are fewer and fewer monopolies. For journalism, that means that we have a print publication, and my sense is that the print publication is going to be the ‘flagship’ way of reaching people for some time.

I think that we have to justify the need for a print publication, and given the just incredible amount of information out there these days, the print publication is part of the agreement we have with our readers to keep watch over all the information out there to let them know what they need to know to do their jobs better. We also post stories daily online — our version of the wire service.

But in addition to providing news and information, a publication needs to provide insight, analysis, and needs to help build community. Blogs are an element of that.

So, in addition to my blog, the FCW Insider, we have a few others. Steve Kelman, a professor at Harvard University’s Kennedy School of Government and the former administrator of the Office of Federal Procurement Policy and an FCW columnist, has a blog. But we have used blogging software for letters to the editor where people can comment on stories, and we run all our corrections in a blog so they are out there for everybody to see.

I like to use my blog to give some of the behind-the-scenes views into the decisions we make. So, yes, I get to both run a publication AND write a blog, but I think the two are very related to one another.

BB: Most PR people (unfortunately) don’t understand what an editorial mission is. Can you explain how FCW’s mission guides your efforts on a day-to-day basis?

CD: FCW’s task is to provide people with information that helps them do their job better. That’s the short version. Information technology is in there too, but just as IT is increasingly embedded in just about everything that everybody does, FCW is expanding beyond just IT.

Late last year, of course, FCW’s parent company, 1105 Media, purchased the former Post Newsweek Tech Media, which included Government Computer News, Washington Technology, the FOSE trade show, and Defense Systems. As a result of that, we have reoriented the publications slightly — actually just emphasized the directions that the publications were going already. GCN is now ‘the technology authority.’ Washington Technology focuses on the business aspects, and FCW is a more policy/management focused publication.

Right after the merger was announced, there was some consternation that this was ‘removing a voice from the community.’ In fact, I think it allows us to focus on stories that we have not been able to tell before. An example of that: Later in June, we are doing the first of several 360-degree looks at issues — in the same week, FCW, GCN, and Washington Technology will all focus on the same issue, each from their own perspective. The first one will be on the Networx telecommunication contract.

As always, our focus is really on the reader, and I think that is more true then ever before.

BB: Could an editorial mission apply to a blog?

CD: The short answer: Absolutely.

As I mentioned, we are there to help people get their jobs done more effectively. But a part of that is building a community, and I think blogs can play a key role in that.

Another example: After the merger, we have had a number of people who live in Maryland and were not all that interested in making the trek out to 1105 Government Information Group’s world headquarters in Falls Church, Va. (I can’t understand THAT!?!) So we are using telework, and we are working to start a blog on telework to tell readers about our experiences — good and bad. What did we get right? What did we get wrong?

BB: Why is the federal marketplace slow to adopt blogs and other new media initiatives?

CD: This is a relatively conservative market. Most government employees, for example, are reluctant to comment on blogs. They are reluctant to go into a webinar and ask questions. They often don’t like to do it at conferences, so…

It is part of the reason I’m so fascinated by all these Web 2.0 technologies and by the changing demographics of both the federal workforce and the U.S. population. Web 2.0 technologies are based on the idea that all of us are smarter then any one of us. That is a significant change in thinking for government. The traditional government model has been that information is power, so the more information I have, the more powerful I am. Web 2.0 throws that on its head.

Some agencies are embracing these ideas. The Defense Department’s network-centric operations model is that information gets posted on secure networks immediately, essentially. So a satellite photo gets posted. That allows a soldier to do his or her own analysis to find what is most important for that person, rather then having some analyst in Langley or wherever determine what the soldier should know.

That seems like a powerful model.

You look at the Virginia Tech tragedy. Students didn’t get their information from newspapers, certainly, or even from CNN. It was FaceBook and MySpace. They provided each other with the intelligence and analysis they needed to make decisions.

It’s a more nuanced world these days, I think, with fewer blacks and whites and many more shades of gray. And when you look at the pace of change in recent years — it just gets faster. I think most people assume that is going to continue. So… put on your seat belts…

BB: What’s going to be the tipping point?

CD: It’s an evolution, not a revolution, and we’re seeing it happen already.

BB: How has FCW Insider impacted the marketplace?

CD: You tell me! [Editor's Nope: Quite a lot, check out our write-up of Chris's blog in this federal blogging round-up.]

BB: What tips would you offer other bloggers in the federal marketplace?

CD: I guess I’d offer up a warning that blogging is much more difficult then it may seem. It’s almost like it is a full-time job, for goodness sake.

Have an idea what you want to do. There are all different kinds of blogs. I actually think blogs got a bad name because there is a misconception that it is people just posting what they do for the day or opinions on something that they know nothing about. Those blogs certainly are out there, but blogs fall into all kinds of categories.

There are news blogs. For example, the Wall Street Journal turned it’s popular Washington Wire column into a blog, and it is tidbits of news from their reporters — items that you won’t find other places.

There are blogs focusing on specific niches. MediaBistro hosts the FishbowlDC blog, which is all about DC journalism.

And then there are the very creative blogs. I have a friend who is spending the next few months only eating local foods — foods that a grown within 150 miles of DC. She blogs about what she finds, what works, what does. Very creative!

Understand that this takes time. Blogging has to be pretty much a couple-times-a-week thing. Otherwise write an occasional column or something. A successful blog needs regular posts or else, why does it exist. And that takes time.

Embrace the power of crowds. There is a wonderful book out by Don Tapscott called Wikinomics, where he talks about the power of tapping into these communities. Sun CEO Jonathan Schwartz blogs and he said that he will sometimes get push back from angry managers who tell him that the blog contradicts what this manager is telling his Sun employees. Schwartz said that his response to those managers is, ‘Too bad.’

A blog can be an opportunity to communicate with… well, everybody. Talk about having a consistent message.

 

Creating Social Media Content? Use an Editorial Mission

One of things we do at Livingston Communications with our clients’ corporate social media initiatives is encourage them to create editorial missions. Great publications use an editorial mission to guide their content creation and fulfill a purpose. Unwaveringly that content is written to educate or inform readers, listeners or viewers about a particular or general subject matter. If content wavers from the mission, it’s often discarded by a managing or executive editor whose job revolves around fulfilling the editorial mission and serving the community. Since corporations are now creating media content on a regular basis, it only makes sense for them to adopt this editorial best practice.

Unfortunately, many practitioners are unable to guide their clients in this sense. A classic public relations error involves not understanding targeted publications’ missions and what they write about. This often leads to horrific rants from reporters, some of which make it to the blogosphere.

When asked for a Buzz Bin interview (to be published later today) if an editorial mission can benefit a blog, FCW Executive Editor and author of the FCW Insider blog said, “Absolutely.” Marketing minds have to understand the importance of editorial missions, not only for outbound PR efforts, but for their own new media efforts. By sticking to an editorial mission statement, the new media stays on track, creating value for its community by providing regular, intelligent copy that stays on topic.

Creating value builds opportunity in a win-win fashion for both your organization and your larger community. In this particular instance, valuable and well structured content towards a social networks needs allows you to contribute, participate and garner respect. By create content that better suits the social network’s needs, they will inherently come to trust your effort, and will want to work with you.

Creating the Right Editorial Mission Can Be Difficult

How cool would it be for [BMW loyalists] to interface directly with a BMW representative on a regular basic, asked Todd Defren of SHIFT Media. “Pretty cool. And more importantly, it would show visitors to the highly-trafficked blog that BMW truly cared about its customers and prospective buyers. I recognize that there are challenges for any company to scale and train and monitor a group of “community managers� that could serve as adjuncts to the marketing group. But what’s worth doing that isn’t going to be a challenge?�

And that’s really the rub. Going through the difficulty of creating value for the community so they find it worthwhile (a.k.a. cool for BMW owners). This requires a) knowing what the community wants, b) understanding the intrinsic value the company has to offer, and c) being creative enough to deliver this value in a way that’s interesting and compelling. This is where the art of marketing can help your new media initiative.

There’s one major pitfall to avoid in an editorial mission: Trying to overtly promote the company. This error remains one of the most common reasons corporate new media initiatives fail. Companies engage in social media because they want to market themselves, and they think new media forms are just another way to promote their wares. This error creates blogs that are never read, videos that are never played, and podcasts that don’t buyers don’t download.

Promotional blogs bore the casual social network member. Sales pitches have no inherent value to someone whose interested in the company’s general category. Getting sold to fails to address why they’re surfing the social network. Content must appeal to the community, and this means giving it valuable, interesting content. Promotion only works when it creates substantial value for your community. That doesn’t mean a corporation should create yet another day in the life blog.

“If you want to create a blog that covers your industry rather than offering the typical company diary, that’s fine, too — even if the blog pharisees criticize you for not adhering to blog orthodoxy,â€? said Scott Baradell in a recent blog post. “Ultimately, it will be the quality of what you produce that will matter — not whether your ideas fit into someone else’s box.â€?

Content should be authentic, providing information that’s inside the organization’s natural and obvious areas of expertise. The organization’s subject matter expertise represents its primary source of value to a community. Further, sharing relevant and interesting subject matter-specific content allows the company to build its image as a community leader or expert.

 

New Media Nouveaux Conference Set for July 13

nmn-themeart.jpg

Success In the City announced the New Media Nouveaux Conference today. Diva Marketing blog author Toby Bloomberg’s our main keynote. I will be the set-up keynote, presenting the findings from my forthcoming book, Now Is Gone.
Additional top marketing and social media minds that will be speaking include:

“The era of early adopters is over, and now every business must consider whether or not to engage in new media,” said Cynthia de Lorenzi, CEO of Success in the City. “The social networking revolution is moving quickly. By recognizing the best new media techniques, businesses can better manage relationships with their communities through proper social media outreach initiatives. New Media Nouveaux will help executives grasp how and why social media strategies smartly deployed< can benefit their business."

Don't miss this conference folks, it promises to be the best social media event in DC this year. Full program and registration is available at: http://www.pivotalbrands.com/clients/nmn/NMN-brochure.pdf.

 

Federal News Radio Social Media Spot

Check out this radiocast of Presto Vivace’s Alice Marshall, IBM’s John Kamensky and I discussing social media trends in the federal marketplace.

Social Media has taken off, and the most mature aspect of social media is blogging. How is it used in industry for both internal and external communications, for outbound marketing/PR and strategy development? Is Second Life the next generation of blogging? In government, in secure environments, the feds are beginning to share ideas, ask questions and more. The IBM Center for the Business of Government has a blogging study coming out at the end of June: The Blogging Revolution: Government in the Age of Web 2.0. Guest Geoff Livingston has a social media book coming out this fall – Now Is Gone.

 

The Godfather of B2G Marketing Speaks

mark.jpg We watched one Godfather ride into the distance last night, and given the popularity of last week’s “state of federal blogging” post we decided to hail another Godfather. Mark Amtower literally wrote the book on Business-to-Government (B2G) marketing and has been dubbed by Entrepreneur magazine as the go-to B2G marketing guru. While getting ready for Mark’s radio show on Federal News Radio, I took the time to ask Mark what he thought about social media and the current state of B2G marketing. Here are his answers (also, check out his new blog: “Not that I have an opinion.”)

BB: You’ve seen the face of federal marketing change quite a bit over the past 30 years. What’s your perspective on the latest trend, new media?

MA: While still trying to get my arms around it, I have experimented with podcasting (2005/very early 2006) and migrated to land radio (my shows are archived at my sites and the radio station), and I just started blogging this week. From the blogs I have seen, only a few really strike me as worth spending any time with. However, as the demographics for marketers – and business/govt consumers shifts, these new media outlets will rapidly come into seriously play. You cannot afford to ignore these media.

BB: What’s your most memorable moment as a marketer?

MA: The first time I was profiled in a major publication stands out (not that it happens often!). Marketing Computers (an AdWeek publication, unfortunately no longer with us!), one of the first publications with an edge, profiled me in March of 1994 – four pages of photos/interview – and they sent down a team for a Capitol Hill photo shoot! The photo shoot occurred the day after my first child, Elora, was born – which is a big reason it sticks out.

More recently, I was asked to speak at the 22nd annual Outlook (fed budget) conference (this year). Before going on stage to speak, I remembered attending my first Outlook 20 or so years back, looking around the room and thinking – wow, these are the people I read about if GCN and FCW and I am in the room with them. Then I was on the stage, speaking, always a rush. Then I was receiving pretty good applause.

Pretty cool to be up there looking out, not being the wide-eyed novice looking at the luminaries!

BB: Why is the federal marketplace slow to adopt blogs and other new media initiatives?

MA: The federal market has rarely been a cutting edge in marketing tactics. But, he who strikes first with a good-to-great blog could be king. Same w/ podcast or other audio.

That’s why I started my radio show 16 months ago. I wanted the first and best show on the business of government. The average age of government employees is also on the high side – so you deliver messages the way people look for them, and these people are not habitual bloggers or IPod’ers.

BB: What’s going to be the tipping point?

MA: When there are more people under 35 than over 35 in the B2G market – on both sides of the fence. Those of us who are older and who have not embraced the new stuff will be left in the cyber-dust. This will not be that far into the future – I think maybe 3-4 years, max.

BB: How has FCW Insider impacted the marketplace?

MA: Very little as we are a market of slow adopters. The migration of Bob Brewin to Gov Exec (from FCW) will have no discernable impact, either, especially because he’s cyber. The Insider has some edge, but not enough to really be different than the web site. Dorobek does a good blog, though, one of the very few I have actually left comments on.

BB: You recently started an open Government Marketing Forum. How will this help the marketplace?

MA: A live Forum where people can meet, greet, network, put faces to names. There is really nothing like this in the government market for sales and marketing folks. Throw in a little education, keep it bi-monthly (frequent enough, but not a burn out frequency), and we should have 75-100 people for each.

I think it’s important for marketing and sales folks to see who else is out there, to know them. Too often I run across people who think they are stars, and they aren’t. They have no perspective. The stars in this market are the agencies, and the programs, and the contracts – not the people.

BB: If you could only pass on three tips to federal marketers, what would they be?

MA: First, stay current – read the publications and look at the web sites. To be good, you have to maintain a working knowledge of the market. Knowing more than your competitor gives you the edge. Never – NEVER – think you know it all. No one does.

Second, network and develop a solid network of people who also study the market. Make sure you have all manner of experts in your circle: Business development, sales, marketing, legal, bid and proposal, program management, research – everything. All of these things interlock, and we all need people we can do favors for in the hopes that those favors will be returned. If you have the right kind of network, it pays massive dividends. Find someone to model, get them to be your mentor.
Third – develop a point of view. This is what really makes someone stand out and stand apart in this market – an educated opinion. Whether with a blog, or in traditional print media, or on the radio, at a conference or meeting, or just over lunch, be worth listening to. If you are not staying current, or just reiterate what others say, no one cares and your network of market pros disintegrates into dust, or fills with ditto-heads. You don’t have to have an edge to have an opinion, but you have to be educated in the nuances to have an opinion worth listening to.

 

Thank You

The Buzz Bin is now ranked as a top 50,000 blog in the world, according to Technorati. We appreciate your interest, continued readership, and value the time you take to read our stuff. It’s our intent to continue to provide valuable information on this blog. If you would like to make a suggestion or request, please contact me at geoff [at] livingstonbuzz [dot] com.

 

A Letter to Doubting PR Practitioners

So I had a client speak at the DC Chamber last week, and another speaker, a PR pro (who shall remain un-named) says, “Blogs will be dead in two years, and businesses shouldn’t invest in them.” Of course, I had to explain my thoughts on this to my client (thanks, Joe Smith for your incompetent remarks).

Here’s the deal, blogs have been around for ten years. Social media’s getting hotter, not colder. Blogs are part of that, and those of us who have learned how to use them effectively to create a dialog with our communities won’t stop.

Here’s the facts: “2006 was the year when the programmable Web eclipsed the static Web every time: flickr beat webshots; Wikipedia beat Britannica; Blogger beat CNN; Epinions beat Consumer-Reports; Upcoming beat evite; Google Maps beat MapQuest; MySpace beat friendster; and craigslist beat Monster,â€? write authors Don Tapscott and Anthony Williams in their brilliant book Wikinomics (p.38).

I’m tired of PR practitioners who won’t get on board. Here’s the deal: We know you feel threatened. We know you can’t control the message anymore. It’s OK, believe it or not, this new social media environment makes your job easier.

Consider Webster’s definition of public relations, “Relations with general public as through publicity; specifically, those functions of a corporation, organization, etc. concerned with attempting to create favorable public opinion for itself.” What better way to do that than have a conversation directly with the public? Enter social media.

Some call the impact of social media as the next generation public relations or PR 2.0. Others like Kami Huyse feel its a return to the true mission of PR. Everyone agrees that it’s about getting down in the street and creating a better relationship with an organization’s community.

With each passing day, the gap between out-dated tactics and current marketing needs widens. It’s incumbent upon communicators to learn new media, not just from a theoretical level, but as practitioners. Without knowledge of how social media forms work, our ability to effectively counsel executives and clients is incomplete. The revolution’s impact on real business marketing campaigns demands our professional attention. And running away from this responsibility hurts the business of public relations and our clients, not to mention your career.

 

Congrats to the Helios HR Apollo Awards Winners

I’ve worked for companies that emphasize employee growth and development, and it makes you work all the harder. At least that’s been my experience. The company wants you to succeed, and as a result you want to succeed. But I’ve also worked for companies who don’t invest in their employees. It’s a tough place to be.

So the ones that do invest deserve be recognized. This morning I attended 2007 Helios HR Apollo Awards breakfast ceremony where four companies who are committed to offering meaningful workplace experiences were honored.

The award winners are:

Emerging Company
20 and fewer employees:
Market Connections, Inc. http://www.marketconnectionsinc.com/

Small Company
21-100 employees:
SPADAC Inc. http://www.spadac.com/

Mid-Size Company
of 101-1,000 employees:
Dimension Data North America www.dimensiondata.com/na/

Large Company
1,001 or more employees:
ICF International http://www.icfi.com/

These companies lead the efforts in establishing best practices. Our hats go off to each and every winner. Congratulations and thank you for your commitment.

 

Guest Blogging about Sprite Yard at TIA Telecommunities

In addition to my regular posts, for the next couple of weeks I will guest blog at TIA’s Telecommunites, a new effort revolving around the telecom industry. This effort, led by former reporter Ian Martinez, has a lot of exciting potential in an industry segment that’s not fully populated in the blogosphere. Anyway, today I posted on the Coca-Cola company’s latest virtual marketing endeavor, Sprite Yard and I thought it’d be interesting for Buzz Bin readers. Check it out.